Getting three quotes is good advice, but comparing them can be harder than it sounds. Prices can vary a lot, and the reason is usually what each contractor has, or hasn't, included.
Here's how to compare quotes fairly so you can make a confident decision.
Check the quotes are for the same job
The most common reason for a big difference in price is a difference in scope. One quote might include skips, making good, decoration and coordinating other trades. Another might only cover the joinery.
Ask each contractor for a written breakdown of what's included, and compare them line by line.
Look for what's excluded
A good quote is just as clear about what isn't included. Common exclusions to watch for:
- Skip hire and waste removal
- Plastering, decorating or tiling
- Electrical and plumbing work
- Building warrant and drawing fees
- Materials you're expected to supply
If a quote doesn't mention these at all, ask.
Understand provisional sums
Sometimes a contractor can't price an item accurately until work starts, for example repairs to joists that can't be seen yet. These are often shown as provisional sums. That's normal and honest, but make sure you understand how they'll be confirmed and agreed.
Ask about timescales
When can they start, and how long will the job take on site? A realistic programme is a good sign. A contractor who promises a very quick finish without seeing the property properly may be guessing.
Ask how they'll communicate
The most common complaint about building work isn't quality, it's communication. Ask who your point of contact will be and how you'll be kept updated. At Astonish Joiners, clear communication from quote to completion is something we take seriously.
Check reviews and previous work
Read reviews, ask to see photos of similar projects, and if possible speak to previous clients. Look for comments about tidiness, timekeeping and how problems were handled.
Beware of quotes that seem too good
A much lower price can mean corners will be cut, items have been left out, or extras will be added later. The cheapest quote isn't always the cheapest job.
What a good quote looks like
- Clearly describes the work
- Lists what's included and excluded
- Explains any provisional sums
- Gives a realistic start date and duration
- Comes from someone who has actually looked at the job
We provide free, no-obligation quotes and always try to make them clear and straightforward. Contact us to arrange yours, or see our full range of services.
Planning a project like this?
Astonish is a family-run joinery and building firm based in Newmains and working across Scotland. Tell us about the job for straight advice and a free written quote.


